Review: ForumNG for Moodle 2

February 28, 2012

Today’s plugin for review is ForumNG and I was using Moodle 2.2 for this review.

Background

This forum plugin has been around for Moodle 1.9 for a few years now. It is created by The Open University in the UK, and is maintained by their internal team including Sam Marshall. The module had a beta-release in September 2011 and there has been no production release since. However, as there has been a few fixes and changes since then that are only available on the github site I used the code from there for the review. There has been talk on and off about this code replacing the built-in forums in Moodle a while back, time will tell.

What does it do?

This is a Moodle activity plugin which is an alternative option to the standard Forums within Moodle. Like the OU Wiki module, this can sit alongside the original forum activities as it is completely independent. There will be times you may want to use one or both systems depending on the use case.

The forum has some key extra features which make it quite a nice tool to use including:

  • Easy to use  Ajax driven User Interface
  • Unique discussion view, with expanding posts
  • A friendly star system for ratings.
  • Sticky Posts
  • Discussion locking
  • Multiple file attachments
  • Flagging posts
  • Private one to one discussions between individual students and teachers
  • Draft options for posts

However, one which I particularly like (and something which Juan Leyva just made for Moodle 2 normal forum  see last comment ) is a single thread subscription rather than for the whole forum.

So enough about the features onto the rest of the review…

Is it simple to install?

There is a zip available in the official Moodle plugins database, however for the purpose of the review I downloaded the most recent codebase from Github. It does say that it is not frequently updated which is a pity! But at least github is there. It is a normal Moodle module, so once I downloaded it I created a folder called forumng in my moodle 2 site under /mod. I then uploaded the contents of the zip to this folder.

Logging into the Moodle 2 site as admin, I was prompted to upgrade to install the plugin, and all the subplugins (image below) This install went fine with no reported errors.

ForumNG install

ForumNG install

As mentioned in the introduction there are a lot of features. As you can see, there are a lot of parts to ForumNG when it installs. There was also quite a few global settings for ForumNG but as with most of my reviews, I left them all default.

Is there documentation for it?

Unlike the OU wiki which is simplicity, this is a complex feature rich plugin. The Moodle Docs page provides good information on the different features, releases and a short FAQ. It also links to the OUs forum quickstart guide which is an essential read!

There are forums discussions and the README also provides the essential information for installation.

Is it easy for the teacher/admin to use?

When creating the forum, the teacher is given options to select the forum type. Unlike the standard Moodle forum, there are only two types available -  The standard forum or the Study Advice (which is the one to one with student/teacher format).

The teacher can also set ratings,  limit posts times, remove old discussions and limit users to a number of posts per day.

Once the forum is created you see the following on the screen.

Empty ForumSo you need to add a discussion now.

The add discussion is somewhat similar to the native Moodle forum, however you immediately notice one change – the option to make the discussion a STICKY.

add-discussion

ForumNG Add Discussion

You can also save the discussion as a draft for completion at a later stage.

One feature I really like is the ability to specify the time which the discussion appears for students. So you can preload your forum with questions just as you would line up quiz or assignment deadlines. In practice this means that when it is hidden students do not see the discussion at all. However or moderators, it will show on the discussion list in grey and with a small clock icon.

ForumNG View discussion, sticky and timed image

ForumNG View discussion, sticky and timed image

I can think of a number of use cases where this is just very helpful. For example, a timed Sticky to provide a reminder to students of something important deadline wise. Funky huh? :)

Once you have created the forum discussion the first entry looks is quite straight forward.

There are quite a number of buttons at the bottom which give the teacher direct control over the discussion thread. These are:#

  • Discussion option (easy access to Display and sticky options)
  • Lock (enables you to post a closing post and then prohibit any more posts on the discussion)
  • Merge (enables you to merge to different discussions into one)
  • Copy  (enables you to copy the discussion to another forum – which is good for archiving great examples)
  • Delete
  • Export (enables you to export to the portfolio api options and gives you the option to choose whole discussion or selected posts)
  • Forward by email (enables you to create an email to a user of the forum discussion and gives you the option to choose whole discussion or selected posts)
  • Print (creates a block-less view of the forum discussion and gives you the option to print discussion or selected posts)
ForumNG View Discussion

ForumNG View Discussion

When you have multiple discussions, you can then set a discussion to be at the top always rather than them changing with new posts. This is the sticky option, and is viewed below with the Green icon on the discussion box.

ForumNG View discussions

ForumNG View discussions

Is it easy for the learner/student to use?

When a student goes to create a thread it is quite straight forward. Replying to an existing thread is ever simpler. The reply box appears below the post you want to reply to without reloading the page and if the student runs out of time to submit he can save a draft until later.

ForumNG Draft

ForumNG Draft

If a discussion has been deemed important to read, it has probably been stickied so will appear at the top.

The ease of use of the interface makes ForumNG quite attractive to some.

Does it do what it promises?

The forum has two nice useful use cases available for it that provide a multitude of options for teachers. The interface is easy to use and the number of neat user-friendly features just make the whole experience great for the teacher and the student.

You may use the Moodle forum still for some particular use cases and it has some options that ForumNG does not but once you have got forumNG, you will see the specific benefits of the timed posts, the nice UI and the extra options for the discussion view page.

Of course one option that some are arguing for is to have those sought after features in the core Moodle forum or have one module with the blend of both sets of options.  I can’t wait!

 

Stars: 4 out of 5 stars for this plugin

**Standard Reminder**

These reviews check out the plugin for usability not for security. If you are considering installing any module on your site you should also check that is secure and does not impact the server performance.

 

Creative Commons Licence
This work by Gavin Henrick is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Optimization WordPress Plugins & Solutions by W3 EDGE